Avadon: The Black Fortress

This is a thumbs sideways review, but ever slightly more to the positive side.
I really enjoyed the setting, and story of the game. There were some cliché moments here and there, but also some unexpected events that made it worthwhile.
The writing is good, and the gameplay is passable. There are unfortunately a lot of essential features missing from such an RPG. The tracking of quests is not done well, and it was often difficult to remember the locations of NPCs who originally gave me a quest.
The quests also lacked a lot of important information, and only displayed the initial goal. Once the quest was updated, and there was a next step, the quest information didn't reflect that.
The biggest annoyance with the game, is at times, your party members would spontaneously decide to disappear on their personal missions. The big problem with that is they took all the gear you gave them, and you couldn't take it back unless you knew the moment before they would leave.
The store page also claims there are "hundreds of magical items to find". Okay, sure...hundreds of absolute garbage magical items, yes! I struggled to find anything actually useful, as every item or enchantment has something like +5% melee damage, or +10% protection against poison damage. Such useless attributes which didn't make my characters feel any more powerful in the slightest.
You also get scarabs, which are kind of like magical charms that give you abilities. I might as well have glued trash to myself instead, the little good they did. And so few scarabs, as well! Throughout the game, I had found only enough to fully equip 3 characters. I might have had one extra.
Finally, the last two or three quests in the game are insufferable in terms of combat. Every corner you turn, another enemy awaits. I had done quite some internal screaming each time I encountered yet another wizard with charm, knockback, or stun spells.
Perhaps I built my character incorrectly, because the struggle was real. I became a potion addict, chugging multiple bottles at the same time, and still being stun-locked into death at the very end of the game. It soured the experience, which up until the end, was rather positive.
To get the best experience out of this game, I'd suggest looking up some character builds.
Well, that was a lot of negativity, and it's unfortunate. The story was really great, and I enjoyed being a Hand of Avadon. Dispensing justice, and squashing traitors! A very heroic tale, where your work is important, and the rewards are...uh...not so great.

Avadon: The Black Fortress review
This is a good game. I don't know why... but for some reason despite the archaic UI and lack of any kind of music, playing this game just feels like breeze, in a good way. It understands its strengths and weaknesses and does it's best to just present the player a nice and satisfying adventure. These games aren't very pricey either and I think if you like deep RPGs (and even some not so deep) you will get your money's worth. The campaigns in most Spiderweb Software games are very lengthy to be made by such a small team.
This may not be Spiderweb Software's best game but it is a good game nonetheless. I know I did enjoy the writing for the most part so far and I hope I will get to finish this game (currently I'm however stuck in a certain area so it will take a while).

Avadon: The Black Fortress is a deliberately old-school role-playing game that exemplifies Spiderweb Software’s long-standing dedication to narrative depth, meaningful choice, and mechanically rich gameplay over flashy presentation. As the opening chapter of the Avadon trilogy, it introduces players to a morally complex fantasy world where authority, loyalty, and power are constantly in tension. You take on the role of a Hand of Avadon, an elite enforcer serving the Pact, a fragile alliance of nations held together not by trust, but by fear of Avadon’s absolute authority. From the beginning, the game makes it clear that your position grants immense power, but that power comes with consequences that are rarely clean or comfortable.
The world of Lynaeus is one of the game’s strongest elements. It is divided between the Pact lands, which rely on Avadon’s protection, and the Farlands, a hostile region filled with rebels, monsters, and enemies who refuse to submit. What makes the setting compelling is how rarely it presents clear moral binaries. The Pact is not portrayed as purely benevolent, nor are its enemies universally evil. Through dialogue, lore, and quest design, the game repeatedly challenges the player to consider whether maintaining order through fear is justified, and whether rebellion is always wrong. As a Hand, you are both judge and executioner, often forced to choose between outcomes that feel equally troubling.
Character creation plays a significant role in shaping the experience. Players can choose from four distinct classes, each offering a different approach to combat and problem-solving. The Blademaster excels in direct physical confrontation, the Shadowwalker relies on stealth and cunning, the Shaman blends support magic with battlefield control, and the Sorceress wields devastating arcane power. These choices meaningfully affect not only combat strategies but also how certain encounters and challenges feel, encouraging replayability. As you progress, you recruit companions with their own personalities, histories, and opinions, adding another layer of narrative texture and tactical consideration.
Combat in Avadon is fully turn-based and emphasizes positioning, resource management, and thoughtful use of abilities. Encounters often demand careful planning rather than brute force, especially on higher difficulty settings. Enemy variety and encounter design keep battles engaging over the long campaign, and success often depends on understanding synergies between party members. While the system may feel slower or less visually dynamic than modern RPGs, it rewards patience and strategic thinking, staying true to classic CRPG traditions.
The game’s quest design is dense and expansive, offering dozens of side quests alongside a lengthy main story that can easily stretch beyond forty hours. Many of these quests present choices that ripple forward, influencing later events, character reactions, and even the game’s ending. This sense of consequence is one of Avadon’s defining strengths. Decisions are rarely labeled as good or evil, and the game resists reassuring the player that they made the “right” choice. Instead, it presents outcomes shaped by political reality, personal ambition, and the costs of maintaining power.
Visually, Avadon: The Black Fortress embraces simplicity. Its 2D graphics and static environments are functional rather than elaborate, prioritizing clarity and performance over spectacle. While this aesthetic may appear dated to some players, it serves the game’s focus on storytelling and mechanics. The restrained presentation allows the writing and worldbuilding to take center stage, and for many fans of Spiderweb Software, this minimalist approach is part of the studio’s charm. The sound design and music are similarly understated, creating atmosphere without drawing attention away from dialogue and decision-making.
The pacing of the game is structured and purposeful, guiding players through a series of escalating conflicts that slowly reveal deeper fractures within the Pact and Avadon itself. While the world offers freedom to explore side content, the overarching narrative maintains a clear direction, which helps sustain momentum throughout the lengthy campaign. Some players may wish for more open-ended exploration, but the tighter structure ensures that the story remains coherent and impactful.
Overall, Avadon: The Black Fortress is a thoughtful, demanding RPG that rewards players who value narrative complexity, strategic combat, and meaningful choices. It is not designed to cater to modern expectations of cinematic presentation or streamlined mechanics, but instead stands firmly in the tradition of classic role-playing games where writing and player agency matter most. For fans of deep fantasy worlds, morally ambiguous storytelling, and turn-based systems that respect the player’s intelligence, Avadon offers a rich and memorable journey that lays a strong foundation for the rest of the trilogy.
Rating: 7/10

Great RPG ! Well worth a play if you like CRPG

A bit janky but fun for the price.

Good game!